I Read the Whole Rulebook Alone Before I Ever Teach It

Every new game that comes into the house gets the same treatment before it ever hits the Friday table. I take the rulebook, just the rulebook, no components spread out yet, and I sit with a coffee on a Sunday afternoon and read the whole thing cover to cover like it’s a normal book, start to finish, before I’ve touched a single card or token. Dev thinks this is faintly ridiculous. He’s not entirely wrong, most people apparently just wing it off the quick-start guide and figure out the rest at the table, which sounds exhausting to me in a way I don’t think I can fully explain to him.

It started because of one bad teach, years back now, a deckbuilder whose combat resolution I’d skimmed rather than actually read, confident I’d basically gotten the gist from the quick reference, and about turn six of teaching it to four people I realized I’d been explaining a rule backward the entire game. Nobody was mad. I was mortified anyway, the specific kind of mortified that comes from knowing you could’ve prevented it with twenty extra minutes of actual attention instead of assuming you already understood something. I decided that night I wasn’t doing that again, and I haven’t, not once in the years since.

What the ritual actually does, beyond preventing that one specific embarrassment, is let me find the organizational sins before anyone else has to suffer through them live. A rulebook that buries a crucial exception in a sidebar three sections after the rule it modifies, I catch that alone on a Sunday instead of fumbling through it in front of five people on a Friday. One that front-loads all the setup with none of the “why,” I catch that too, and I’ll usually restructure my own teach to lead differently than the book does, start with the goal instead of the components, because that’s how people actually learn a new system.

I’ve started timing myself, unofficially, just out of curiosity about my own patience. Most rulebooks take forty minutes to an hour to read properly alone. The genuinely well organized ones, the kind that respect a reader’s attention and build in the right order, read almost like a good short story, and I notice myself actually enjoying the read separate from whether I even like the game underneath it. The badly organized ones feel like homework, and I resent every one of those forty minutes even when the game itself turns out great once you’re actually playing it. I don’t think this ritual is going away. If anything it’s gotten more entrenched with time, coffee, rulebook, quiet, before anyone else in the house is even awake most Sundays.

← back to the blog